Best Craft Chalk Markers

Looking for the best craft chalk markers?
Discover vibrant, non-toxic chalk markers that deliver bold, erasable designs on glass, chalkboards, and more—offering smooth application and endless creative possibilities.

Unleash vibrant creativity with craft chalk markers that transform ordinary surfaces into bold masterpieces. These markers blend easy-erase convenience with non-toxic, water-based ink for safe, mess-free fun.

Bold lines, endless ideas—from glass windows to chalkboards, these pens deliver crisp, eye-catching designs with zero dust. Whether you’re decorating or doodling, every stroke feels smooth and satisfying.

Need fine tips or jumbo nibs? We’ve got you covered. Craving bright hues or classic white? It’s all here. Ready to create, erase, and repeat? Let’s dive in!

List of Top 10 Craft Chalk Markers

Image Title Best For Price
Loddie Doddie Chalk Markers - Pack of 16, Reversible 6mm Tips - Vibrant Chalkboard Designs with Chalkboard Markers - Easy Erase on Glass & Whiteboards with Dry Erase Pen Loddie Doddie Chalk Markers – Pack of 16, Reversible 6mm Tips – Vibrant Chalkboard Designs with Chalkboard Markers – Easy Erase on Glass & Whiteboards with Dry Erase Pen

Loddie Doddie Chalk Markers are perfect for families, teachers, and artists who love creative fun. They’re great for all ages and easy to use on glass, whiteboards, and blackboards.

View on Amazon (paid link)
Bandle B. Chalk Markers - 8 Vibrant, Erasable, Non-Toxic, Water-Based, Reversible Tips. For Glass or Chalkboard Markers for Businesses, Restaurants, Liquid Drawing Chalk (Vibrant 6mm) Bandle B. Chalk Markers – 8 Vibrant, Erasable, Non-Toxic, Water-Based, Reversible Tips. For Glass or Chalkboard Markers for Businesses, Restaurants, Liquid Drawing Chalk (Vibrant 6mm)

Bandle B. Chalk Markers are perfect for anyone who wants to create eye-catching designs or messages on chalkboards, glass, or other surfaces. Whether you’re a business owner, teacher, or creative at home, these vibrant, erasable markers make it easy to express yourself.

View on Amazon (paid link)
Liquid Chalk Marker Pen - White Dry Erase Marker - Chalkboard Signs, Windows, Blackboard, Glass (6 Pack) 3-6mm Reversible Tip, 3-3mm Fine Tip Liquid Chalk Marker Pen – White Dry Erase Marker – Chalkboard Signs, Windows, Blackboard, Glass (6 Pack) 3-6mm Reversible Tip, 3-3mm Fine Tip

These chalk markers are perfect for teachers, moms, students, artists, kids, and bistro owners who need a kid-safe, odor-free way to write on chalkboards, windows, or glass. Dustless, non-toxic ink wipes off easily with a wet cloth, making them ideal for classrooms, homes, or businesses.

View on Amazon (paid link)
Artsunlvy 8 Colors Chalk Markers, Chalk Pens, Erase Marker, Non-Toxic, Water-Based, Reversible Tips, Chalkboard Markers for Adult, Car Windows, Glass Artsunlvy 8 Colors Chalk Markers, Chalk Pens, Erase Marker, Non-Toxic, Water-Based, Reversible Tips, Chalkboard Markers for Adult, Car Windows, Glass

Perfect for adults who love to create, these markers work on glass, windows, and smooth boards. Great for artists, shop owners, or hobbyists, they offer bold colors and easy erasing.

View on Amazon (paid link)
Timart Extra Fine Tip Chalk Markers (8 Pack 1mm Point), Liquid Chalk Pens - Dry Erase Marker Pens for Blackboard, Chalkboards, Windows, Glass, Bistro, Cars, Signs, Chalkboard Labels Included Timart Extra Fine Tip Chalk Markers (8 Pack 1mm Point), Liquid Chalk Pens – Dry Erase Marker Pens for Blackboard, Chalkboards, Windows, Glass, Bistro, Cars, Signs, Chalkboard Labels Included

These chalk markers are perfect for teachers, artists, or anyone needing vibrant, easy-to-erase designs on non-porous surfaces like glass, whiteboards, or windows. Their 1mm fine tip and neon colors make them ideal for detailed writing, labels, or creative projects.

View on Amazon (paid link)
SFAIH White Liquid Chalk Markers for Blackboard, Glass - [Wet Wipe No Residue] 8 Pack- (4x) 2mm/4mm Reversible & (4x) 0.7mm Fine Tip, Ultra Flow Triple-Tips - Menu, Bistro, Signs, Windows, Food Labels SFAIH White Liquid Chalk Markers for Blackboard, Glass – [Wet Wipe No Residue] 8 Pack- (4x) 2mm/4mm Reversible & (4x) 0.7mm Fine Tip, Ultra Flow Triple-Tips – Menu, Bistro, Signs, Windows, Food Labels

SFAIH White Liquid Chalk Markers are perfect for anyone who wants to create eye-catching signs or labels. Whether you’re a business owner, teacher, or creative individual, these markers are ideal for writing on blackboards, glass, or other non-porous surfaces.

View on Amazon (paid link)
WUO 12 Colors Liquid Chalk Markers, 10mm Jumbo 3-in-1 Nib Window Chalk Markers, Washable Chalkboard Markers for Glass, Windows, Blackboards, Mirrors, Bistro Signage, and DIY Art Crafts WUO 12 Colors Liquid Chalk Markers, 10mm Jumbo 3-in-1 Nib Window Chalk Markers, Washable Chalkboard Markers for Glass, Windows, Blackboards, Mirrors, Bistro Signage, and DIY Art Crafts

WUO 12 Colors Liquid Chalk Markers are perfect for DIY enthusiasts, teachers, and kids who love creating vibrant, washable designs. These markers work great on glass, windows, chalkboards, and mirrors for art, signs, or home decor.

View on Amazon (paid link)
SILENART Liquid Chalk Markers - 8 Vibrant Colors - Chalkboard Markers for Blackboard Glass Window Car Dry Erase Board Acrylic Calendar Board Whiteboard- Wet Erase SILENART Liquid Chalk Markers – 8 Vibrant Colors – Chalkboard Markers for Blackboard Glass Window Car Dry Erase Board Acrylic Calendar Board Whiteboard- Wet Erase

SILENART Liquid Chalk Markers are perfect for anyone who loves to create and decorate. Whether you’re a teacher, artist, or parent, these markers make writing and drawing fun and easy.

View on Amazon (paid link)
Crafty Croc Chalk Markers, 4-Pack White, Erasable and Non-Toxic, 6mm Reversible Tip Liquid Chalk Pens for Chalkboards, Glass, Windows, and Mirrors Crafty Croc Chalk Markers, 4-Pack White, Erasable and Non-Toxic, 6mm Reversible Tip Liquid Chalk Pens for Chalkboards, Glass, Windows, and Mirrors

Crafty Croc Chalk Markers are perfect for teachers, parents, and business owners. They work great on chalkboards, glass, and mirrors for clear writing that erases cleanly. These non-toxic pens are safe for kids and feature a reversible tip for both bold lines and precise details.

View on Amazon (paid link)
LANA & LUCA Liquid Chalk Markers for Blackboards - Wet Erase Marker Pens - Chalk Markers for Chalkboards Signs, Windows, Blackboard, Glass - 6mm Reversible Tip (8 Pack) - Vintage Colors Multicolor LANA & LUCA Liquid Chalk Markers for Blackboards – Wet Erase Marker Pens – Chalk Markers for Chalkboards Signs, Windows, Blackboard, Glass – 6mm Reversible Tip (8 Pack) – Vintage Colors Multicolor

These markers are perfect for teachers, restaurants, and event planners who need bold, easy-to-erase writing on chalkboards, windows, or glass. With vibrant neon colors, a reversible tip, and a 100% satisfaction guarantee, they make creative projects and daily updates simple and fun.

View on Amazon (paid link)

Detailed Reviews

Unleash your creativity with the top craft chalk markers! These vibrant markers deliver bold colors, effortless erasing, and versatile use on glass, whiteboards, and more.

Perfect for artists, teachers, or families, they’re non-toxic, kid-safe, and built for endless designs. Every pick blends smooth writing and crisp details for standout projects.

Trust expert picks tested by real users—no dusty chalk, just clean, bright results every time. Ready to create? Dive in and find your ideal match!

1. Loddie Doddie Chalk Markers – Pack of 16, Reversible 6mm Tips – Vibrant Chalkboard Designs with Chalkboard Markers – Easy Erase on Glass & Whiteboards with Dry Erase Pen

Loddie Doddie Chalk Markers - Pack of 16, Reversible 6mm Tips - Vibrant Chalkboard Designs with Chalkboard Markers - Easy Erase on Glass & Whiteboards with Dry Erase Pen

Unleash your creativity with Loddie Doddie Chalk Markers! These vibrant markers bring chalkboard designs to life on glass and whiteboards. They are perfect for decorating and making thoughtful gifts.

Transform any surface into a masterpiece! Use these pastel chalk markers on windows and whiteboards for eye-catching designs. Cleanup is a breeze with these easy-erase pens.

These versatile art tools offer endless creative possibilities. Enjoy family fun time with these non-toxic and erasable markers.

Pros Cons
  • Vibrant colors create bold, eye-catching designs
  • Effortless erasing wipes clean from glass or whiteboards
  • Versatile use on glass, whiteboards, or chalkboards
  • Non-toxic formula safe for kids and adults
  • Endless creativity for art, notes, or daily inspiration
  • Markers may dry out quickly if not sealed properly
  • Reversible tips might wear down faster with frequent use
  • Ink may stain surfaces if not wiped promptly

Perfect For:

Loddie Doddie Chalk Markers are perfect for families, teachers, and artists who love creative fun. They’re great for all ages and easy to use on glass, whiteboards, and blackboards.

Ready to Purchase?

2. Bandle B. Chalk Markers – 8 Vibrant, Erasable, Non-Toxic, Water-Based, Reversible Tips. For Glass or Chalkboard Markers for Businesses, Restaurants, Liquid Drawing Chalk (Vibrant 6mm)

Bandle B. Chalk Markers - 8 Vibrant, Erasable, Non-Toxic, Water-Based, Reversible Tips. For Glass or Chalkboard Markers for Businesses, Restaurants, Liquid Drawing Chalk (Vibrant 6mm)

Unleash your creativity with Bandle B. Chalk Markers! These 8 vibrant colors make your designs pop. They are non-toxic and water-based.

Easily write on chalkboards, glass, and other smooth surfaces. Use them as window markers or dry erase markers. Your messages will be eye-catching.

Switch between fine and bold lines with the reversible tip. It’s simple to change your writing style. Get ready for smooth, bright colors every time you write!

Pros Cons
  • 8 Vibrant Colors for eye-catching designs.
  • Erasable & Non-Toxic – safe and easy to clean.
  • Works on Glass, Chalkboards, or Tile – any smooth surface!
  • Reversible Tip creates fine or bold lines effortlessly.
  • 5-Star Guarantee – love it or we fix it!
  • Frequent shaking required to mix ink, which may be inconvenient.
  • Only 8 color options may limit creativity for some users.
  • Erasable ink might leave residue if not cleaned promptly.

Perfect For:

Bandle B. Chalk Markers are perfect for anyone who wants to create eye-catching designs or messages on chalkboards, glass, or other surfaces. Whether you’re a business owner, teacher, or creative at home, these vibrant, erasable markers make it easy to express yourself.

Ready to Purchase?

3. Liquid Chalk Marker Pen – White Dry Erase Marker – Chalkboard Signs, Windows, Blackboard, Glass (6 Pack) 3-6mm Reversible Tip, 3-3mm Fine Tip

Liquid Chalk Marker Pen - White Dry Erase Marker - Chalkboard Signs, Windows, Blackboard, Glass (6 Pack) 3-6mm Reversible Tip, 3-3mm Fine Tip

Tired of dusty, messy chalk? Upgrade your writing game with these brilliant Liquid Chalk Marker Pens! This 6-pack of white dry-erase markers is perfect for making your signs, windows, and blackboards pop with vibrant, smudge-free lines.

They’re fun and easy to use. These markers are kid-safe and odor-free. Plus, they wipe off cleanly with a damp cloth.

Whether you’re a teacher, artist, or business owner, these markers are designed for everyone. Experience the LANA & LUCA promise of satisfaction, ensuring you’ll love these versatile and brilliant chalk markers.

Pros Cons
  • Dust-free and odorless for a clean, safe experience.
  • Easy cleanup with just a wet wipe.
  • Versatile for all ages and uses.
  • Non-toxic and eco-friendly for peace of mind.
  • Satisfaction guaranteed with the LANA & LUCA promise.
  • Not for porous surfaces, limiting where you can use them.
  • Tips may wear out with heavy or frequent use.
  • White ink might be less visible on light backgrounds.

Perfect For:

These chalk markers are perfect for teachers, moms, students, artists, kids, and bistro owners who need a kid-safe, odor-free way to write on chalkboards, windows, or glass. Dustless, non-toxic ink wipes off easily with a wet cloth, making them ideal for classrooms, homes, or businesses.

Ready to Purchase?

4. Artsunlvy 8 Colors Chalk Markers, Chalk Pens, Erase Marker, Non-Toxic, Water-Based, Reversible Tips, Chalkboard Markers for Adult, Car Windows, Glass

Artsunlvy 8 Colors Chalk Markers, Chalk Pens, Erase Marker, Non-Toxic, Water-Based, Reversible Tips, Chalkboard Markers for Adult, Car Windows, Glass

Artsunlvy 8 Colors Chalk Markers spark creativity with vibrant, water-based ink. They blend bold hues like red, blue, and green for lively art or writing. Each set includes free 24 chalk labels to boost your designs.

The reversible tips switch between fine and bold lines with ease. Use them on glass, whiteboards, or car windows for crisp, erasable marks. Just avoid porous surfaces—test first for best results.

These markers are odorless and washable, safe for all ages. Ideal for artists, teachers, or anyone who loves crafting with color.

Pros Cons
  • 8 vibrant colors to spark imagination.
  • Dual-tip for versatile writing.
  • Easy to erase on non-porous surfaces.
  • Safe and odorless for all users.
  • Perfect for creative expression.
  • Works only on non-porous surfaces.
  • Water-based ink may smudge easily.
  • Reversible tips might wear out faster.

Perfect For:

Perfect for adults who love to create, these markers work on glass, windows, and smooth boards. Great for artists, shop owners, or hobbyists, they offer bold colors and easy erasing.

Ready to Purchase?

5. Timart Extra Fine Tip Chalk Markers (8 Pack 1mm Point), Liquid Chalk Pens – Dry Erase Marker Pens for Blackboard, Chalkboards, Windows, Glass, Bistro, Cars, Signs, Chalkboard Labels Included

Timart Extra Fine Tip Chalk Markers (8 Pack 1mm Point), Liquid Chalk Pens - Dry Erase Marker Pens for Blackboard, Chalkboards, Windows, Glass, Bistro, Cars, Signs, Chalkboard Labels Included

Timart Chalk Markers offer a clean, dust-free way to write. The 1mm fine tip is perfect for detailed designs. Say goodbye to old chalk and hello to vibrant ink.

Enjoy eight bright neon colors that pop on any surface. These long-lasting markers are highly pigmented. They make your creations stand out with ease.

Use them on glass, metal, or boards. Simply wipe clean with a damp cloth. Always test on small areas first to avoid surface damage.

Pros Cons
  • Precision 1mm tip for sharp, detailed lines
  • 8 vivid neon colors that stand out brightly
  • Wipe off easily with a damp cloth
  • Ideal for glass, windows, blackboards, and metal
  • Fun and easy to use for any project
  • Only erasable on non-porous surfaces
  • May damage unsuitable chalkboards if not tested
  • Ultra-fine tips may wear down quickly

Perfect For:

These chalk markers are perfect for teachers, artists, or anyone needing vibrant, easy-to-erase designs on non-porous surfaces like glass, whiteboards, or windows. Their 1mm fine tip and neon colors make them ideal for detailed writing, labels, or creative projects.

Ready to Purchase?

6. SFAIH White Liquid Chalk Markers for Blackboard, Glass – [Wet Wipe No Residue] 8 Pack- (4x) 2mm/4mm Reversible & (4x) 0.7mm Fine Tip, Ultra Flow Triple-Tips – Menu, Bistro, Signs, Windows, Food Labels

SFAIH White Liquid Chalk Markers for Blackboard, Glass - [Wet Wipe No Residue] 8 Pack- (4x) 2mm/4mm Reversible & (4x) 0.7mm Fine Tip, Ultra Flow Triple-Tips - Menu, Bistro, Signs, Windows, Food Labels

SFAIH White Liquid Chalk Markers come with 8 pens in two tip sizes: 4mm reversible and 0.7mm fine. These tips let you write bold headlines or tiny labels with ease. The triple-tip design makes writing fun and versatile.

The bright white ink covers dark surfaces perfectly, even from 50 feet away. Use them on glass, blackboards, or plastic for clear, smooth results. They’re great for menus, signs, or food labels.

Clean up is super easy—just wipe with a damp cloth. The non-toxic, odor-free ink is safe for kitchens and restaurants. Perfect for creative projects and daily updates.

Pros Cons
  • Multiple Tip Sizes for bold headlines & fine details
  • Bright White Ink clearly visible on dark surfaces
  • 1-Second Wet Wipe removes marks instantly
  • Safe Non-Toxic Ink for homes and commercial use
  • Works on Glass, Blackboards, Metal & More Surfaces
  • Not permanent: Marks can smudge or fade easily on some surfaces.
  • Limited tip options: Only two sizes available for varied tasks.
  • Drying time varies: May take longer to dry in humid conditions.

Perfect For:

SFAIH White Liquid Chalk Markers are perfect for anyone who wants to create eye-catching signs or labels. Whether you’re a business owner, teacher, or creative individual, these markers are ideal for writing on blackboards, glass, or other non-porous surfaces.

Ready to Purchase?

7. WUO 12 Colors Liquid Chalk Markers, 10mm Jumbo 3-in-1 Nib Window Chalk Markers, Washable Chalkboard Markers for Glass, Windows, Blackboards, Mirrors, Bistro Signage, and DIY Art Crafts

WUO 12 Colors Liquid Chalk Markers, 10mm Jumbo 3-in-1 Nib Window Chalk Markers, Washable Chalkboard Markers for Glass, Windows, Blackboards, Mirrors, Bistro Signage, and DIY Art Crafts

Unleash your creativity with 12 vibrant colors! These liquid chalk markers are perfect for glass, windows, and blackboards. Get ready to make your art pop!

These markers offer an easy, mess-free cleanup. They wipe away with just a wet cloth, leaving no stains.

Make your mark with a 10mm jumbo nib that writes in three ways. They are safe and non-toxic for everyone. Perfect for DIY and home decor!

Pros Cons
  • 12 vibrant colors and bonus stickers spark endless creativity.
  • Easy to erase – no mess or stains on glass/surfaces.
  • 10mm 3-in-1 nib creates wide, medium, or fine lines.
  • Non-toxic and dust-free – safe for kids and classrooms.
  • Works on glass, chalkboards, mirrors, and DIY projects.
  • Not permanent – washes away easily, not for long-term displays.
  • Limited color depth – may appear less vibrant on dark surfaces.
  • Nib wear – heavy use might flatten the tip quickly.

Perfect For:

WUO 12 Colors Liquid Chalk Markers are perfect for DIY enthusiasts, teachers, and kids who love creating vibrant, washable designs. These markers work great on glass, windows, chalkboards, and mirrors for art, signs, or home decor.

Ready to Purchase?

8. SILENART Liquid Chalk Markers – 8 Vibrant Colors – Chalkboard Markers for Blackboard Glass Window Car Dry Erase Board Acrylic Calendar Board Whiteboard- Wet Erase

SILENART Liquid Chalk Markers - 8 Vibrant Colors - Chalkboard Markers for Blackboard Glass Window Car Dry Erase Board Acrylic Calendar Board Whiteboard- Wet Erase

Unleash your creativity with SILENART Liquid Chalk Markers! These 8 vibrant colors bring your ideas to life on a variety of surfaces, from chalkboards to windows.

Experience high quality and easy cleanup. Enjoy bright, bold writing that lasts. These markers are versatile and a joy to use.

Pros Cons
  • Vibrant colors stand out on any surface
  • Smooth, even writing without smudges
  • Lasts longer with high-quality ink
  • Easily wiped clean from smooth surfaces
  • Works on glass, boards, metal, and more
  • Not for porous surfaces like untreated wood or uncoated paper.
  • Wet erase only—may smudge if not wiped properly.
  • Limited color variety compared to other marker sets.

Perfect For:

SILENART Liquid Chalk Markers are perfect for anyone who loves to create and decorate. Whether you’re a teacher, artist, or parent, these markers make writing and drawing fun and easy.

Ready to Purchase?

9. Crafty Croc Chalk Markers, 4-Pack White, Erasable and Non-Toxic, 6mm Reversible Tip Liquid Chalk Pens for Chalkboards, Glass, Windows, and Mirrors

Crafty Croc Chalk Markers, 4-Pack White, Erasable and Non-Toxic, 6mm Reversible Tip Liquid Chalk Pens for Chalkboards, Glass, Windows, and Mirrors

Crafty Croc Chalk Markers make your writing stand out on chalkboards, glass, windows, and mirrors. The bold, clean white color is perfect for clear, visible designs.

Easy to use and erase, these markers leave no mess behind. They’re safe for kids and great for any project.

Pros Cons
  • Bold white ink stands out clearly on dark surfaces.
  • 6mm reversible tip handles both detailed and thick strokes.
  • Works on glass, mirrors, windows, and chalkboards smoothly.
  • Erasable with a damp cloth, leaves no marks or residue.
  • Non-toxic formula safe for kids and classroom use.
  • Limited Surface Compatibility – Only works on non-porous surfaces like glass; not suitable for paper or fabric.
  • Fixed Tip Sizes – Limited to 6mm reversible tips; may not suit all writing needs.
  • No Color Variety – Only available in white; limited creative options.

Perfect For:

Crafty Croc Chalk Markers are perfect for teachers, parents, and business owners. They work great on chalkboards, glass, and mirrors for clear writing that erases cleanly. These non-toxic pens are safe for kids and feature a reversible tip for both bold lines and precise details.

Ready to Purchase?

10. LANA & LUCA Liquid Chalk Markers for Blackboards – Wet Erase Marker Pens – Chalk Markers for Chalkboards Signs, Windows, Blackboard, Glass – 6mm Reversible Tip (8 Pack) – Vintage Colors Multicolor

LANA & LUCA Liquid Chalk Markers for Blackboards - Wet Erase Marker Pens - Chalk Markers for Chalkboards Signs, Windows, Blackboard, Glass - 6mm Reversible Tip (8 Pack) - Vintage Colors Multicolor

Say goodbye to dusty chalk and hello to vibrant, bold colors with LANA & LUCA Liquid Chalk Markers! These fun and easy-to-use markers are perfect for unleashing your creativity. Get ready to make your mark in stunning multicolor!

Need to change your message? No problem! A simple wipe with a wet paper towel makes these markers completely and easily erasable from most smooth surfaces. Enjoy a mess-free experience every time you write.

With the LANA and LUCA Promise, your satisfaction is guaranteed. Experience the joy of effortless creativity today!

Pros Cons
  • Bold, vibrant colors replace dusty chalk for easy, fun writing
  • Wipes off clean with a wet cloth on glass, windows, or boards
  • Satisfaction guaranteed – hassle-free support if you’re not happy
  • 8-pack vintage colors offer creative options for signs or decor
  • Not suitable for porous surfaces
  • May smudge if not wiped quickly
  • Tip durability may decrease with heavy use

Perfect For:

These markers are perfect for teachers, restaurants, and event planners who need bold, easy-to-erase writing on chalkboards, windows, or glass. With vibrant neon colors, a reversible tip, and a 100% satisfaction guarantee, they make creative projects and daily updates simple and fun.

Ready to Purchase?

Buying Guide

Craft chalk markers turn surfaces into vibrant masterpieces. They blend bold color with easy-erase, non-toxic fun for all ages.

  • Tip Size and Versatility: Pick reversible tips for fine lines or bold strokes. Jumbo nibs add drama, while narrow points handle detail.
  • Color Vibrancy and Range: Bright, water-based inks stay vivid on glass or chalkboards. More colors mean endless creative options.
  • Erase Ease: Markers should wipe clean with a damp cloth. Avoid formulas that smudge or leave residue.
  • Safety: Non-toxic, odor-free ink suits kids and classrooms. Check labels for safety certifications.
  • Surface Compatibility: Test on smooth surfaces like glass, metal, or sealed boards. Avoid porous materials unless tested first.
  • Durability: Pigmented ink resists fading on high-traffic surfaces. Choose long-lasting colors for frequent updates.
  • Additional Features: Look for bonus labels, multi-tip designs, or pack sizes that match your project scale.